Strategic Intent

Data.gov’s potential depends on a clear strategic intent. The Draft Data.gov CONOPS’ vision includes key principles, target audience, value to the public and government, and measures of success. Post your best ideas on strategic intent here.

Funding - Data.gov cannot be another unfunded federal mandate

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

Federal agencies are already trying their best to respond to a stream of unfunded mandates. Requiring federal agencies to a) expose their raw data as a service and b) collect, analyze, and respond to public comments requires resources. The requirement to make data accessible to (through) Data.gov should be formally established as a component of one of the Federal strategic planning and performance management frameworks ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

35 votes

Dataset Versioning

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

Perhaps it's there and I don't see it, but it would seem that some kind of automated versioning system needs to be in place. My concern, from a transparency standpoint, would be if there is the capability to overwrite an existing dataset. Even if it is well intentioned, if the original dataset is not preserved, questions could arise as to what has been changed/added/removed. This could also help with datasets that ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

28 votes

Create Scenerios Showcasing Data.gov Contributions for Key Issue

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

Many professional and social circles continue to focus on issues such as climate change, governmental fiscal imbalances, the demographic shift to older populations, depleting resources, health care, and increasing technological complexity. We are about to embark on a new decade and these unresolved issues will follow us. How will Data.gov contribute toward addressing the tough questions we face in the next decade? ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

27 votes

Data Quality - Need process for assuring 'good data' on Data.gov

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

On Page 9 of the CONOP, the example of Forbes' use of Federal data to develop the list of "America's Safest Cities" brings to light a significant risk associated with providing 'raw data' for public consumption. As you are aware, much of the crime data used for that survey is drawn from the Uniformed Crime Reporting effort of the FBI. As self-reported on the "Crime in the United States" website, "Figures used in this ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

23 votes

Post Links to All Agency ICRs Together

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

ICR = Information Collection Request. Example: http://edicsweb.ed.gov/. Each agency has a site like this, but it is sometimes hard to find. If they were posted together, data.gov users could more easily discover interconnections among data sets. The files at each link on the page explain: (1) WHAT data a department wants to collect from the public, and the form that will be used to collect it; (2) WHO must fill out ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

19 votes

Measuring success of Data.gov - a suggested (simple) framework

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

The OMB Open Government Directive published on December 8, 2009 includes what are (in my opinion) some undefined terms and very unrealistic expectations and deadlines for federal agency compliance with the directive. It also did not include any method for assessing progress towards the spirit and intent of the stated objectives. I would like to offer a simple framework that the Data.gov effort can use to work (collaboratively) ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

14 votes

Require agencies to explain why the data is "high value"

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

This entry is a consensus recommendation of seven organizations that work on government transparency of which OpenTheGovernment.org is one. Require agencies to explain why the data is high value by having them designate which of the “high value criteria” the data meets: information that can be used to increase agency accountability and responsiveness; improve public knowledge of the agency and its operations; further ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

14 votes

Require agencies to indicate previous availability of the data

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

This entry is a consensus recommendation of seven organizations that work on government transparency of which OpenTheGovernment.org is one. Require agencies to indicate whether a high value dataset was previously unavailable, available only with a FOIA request, available only for purchase, or available, but in a less user-friendly format. Going forward, this will make it easier to track how agencies are complying with ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

12 votes

Semantic Web and Linked Open Data

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

As additional datasets become exposed through RDF, and described through RDFS/OWL-based ontological definitions, I would like to see the ability to mashup DATA.GOV datasets with the rest of the Linked Open Data cloud, using SPARQL.

http://esw.w3.org/SweoIG/TaskForces/CommunityProjects/LinkingOpenData

Mitchell Ummel

Government/Public Sector Practice

Cutter Research

www.cutter.com

Submitted by

Feedback Score

9 votes

Strategy - Revise CONOP to addess the value to American citizens

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

As currently written, the CONOP only addresses internal activities (means) and doesn't identify the outcomes (ends) that would result from successful implementation of Data.gov. In paragraph 1 the CONOP states "Data.gov is a flagship Administration initiative intended to allow the public to easily find, access, understand, and use data that are generated by the Federal government.", yet there is no discussion about "what ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

9 votes

Data Presentation/Search

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

Rather than organizing the data according to organizational silo's (eg. USDA, HHS, etc) recommend developing an interface that allows for multiple "views" of the same data. Taking Apple's iPhoto software as an example - the single photo dataset can be viewed according to events, photos, faces, or places. This allows the same dataset to be sliced and diced in multiple ways - unearthing interesting connections along the ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

6 votes

Value of Data

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

Using some of the recommendations here, including documenting solid applications of the data, and a 'social network of users' will help to establish and document the 'value' of data by the importance and diversity of data use. Documenting requests for data as has been suggested by others can help with this and some agency agency perceptions(with all due respect) that "numbers" of data sets proffered satisfies the criteria ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

6 votes

Should be simple, but not simplistic

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

The approach to making information available should be simple, but not simplistic. Common things should be simple to achieve, more complex things should be possible. What I mean by this can be seen by contrasting a spreadsheet to a relational database. In my view spreadsheets are "simplistic". Relational databases are really not that much more difficult to use, I would even say they are simple to use. A relational ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

6 votes

Embed a workflow function in DMS for releasability tracking

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

1. Embed a workflow function that provides capability to indicate releasability reviews for required categories within the DMS. As more information is released the need for standardized reviews and assurance that critical reviews have been performed will become more important. While different agencies may have internal protocols for release the requirement for review prior to release is common. Multiple agencies ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

5 votes

Simplify all ideas and comments by building relationships.

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

Please consider:

1) Allowing people to comment on any given comments for a certain idea.

2) Analyze the ideas to show interdepencies and relationships between them.including comments.

3)Just counting number of votes for an idea is not usefull, and may be interpreted differently by different realities.

4)provide a structural meaningful for all inputs received and initiate dialogues to discuss.

Submitted by

Feedback Score

4 votes

FOIA Dashboard

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

This relates to data.gov in a tangential fashion - however perhaps either the data or the dashboard could reside within Data.gov: The idea here, toward government transparency, is to develop a simple, common format for reporting FOIA requests, with a historic and status context, e.g. number of new requests opened in a given month, number of existing closed in a given month, number of requests outstanding broken out by ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

4 votes

information dissemination

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

create a 'google' style search engine. Streamline the govt form data concepts all the way down to forms, all into preceptive categories that allow users to search using any term they can conceive of while trying to look for an agency, form or data.... from the data at CDC to the latest on the oil spill int he Gulf to how to fill out your govt job app and apply for benefits. google.gov!

Submitted by

Feedback Score

2 votes

Protecting the digital borders

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

We need to have all of the IT leaders in the country trained and cognizant of the information security challenges that face our businesses, our intellectual property and our infrastucture. As technology continues to evolve over the coming months and years, portions of the IT infrastructure are falling behind. Let's create a strategic training program and bundle a toolset to make infosec an issue that gets the attention ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

0 votes

Method for searching by expertise, or finding expertise

Stage: Active

Campaign: Strategic Intent

The Data.gov CONOPS provides a great deal of information regarding the governance and advisory support made available by “POCs” and “Data Stewards” and other roles engaged in populating and supporting data on the site. The CONOPS also describes how Personally-Identifiable Information (PII) is protected, both for submitters and those engaged in the governance process. As well, some existing community forums are referenced ...more »

Submitted by

Feedback Score

-9 votes

Displaying all 22 Ideas